The same generation of Australian players that Ange Postecoglou coached are now playing together under other coaches. Let’s see if results got better or worse.
In the above league table After-Ange’s results are for the 6 games since Ange left. With-Ange’s results are for Ange’s last 6 games (no friendlies).
|15/01/19||AC||Australia||3 – 2||Syria (74)|
|11/01/19||AC||Palestine (99)||1 – 2||Australia|
|06/01/19||AC||Australia||0 – 1||Jordan (109)|
|26/06/18||WC||Australia||0 – 2||Peru (11)|
|21/06/18||WC||Denmark (12)||1 – 1||Australia|
|16/06/18||WC||France (7)||2 – 1||Australia|
*All of these matches were at neutral venues.
|15/11/17||WCQ||Australia||3 – 1||Honduras (69)|
|11/11/17||WCQ||Honduras (69)||0 – 0||Australia|
|10/10/17||WCQ||Australia||2 – 1||Syria (73)|
|05/10/17||WCQ||Syria (73)||1 – 1||Australia|
|05/09/17||WCQ||Australia||2 – 1||Thailand (122)|
|31/08/17||WCQ||Japan (55)||2 – 0||Australia|
|25/06/17||COC||Chile (9)||1 – 1*||Australia|
These games are comparable
Right now we have a small sample size, but I will maintain the table until both teams have 33 competitive games, the total number Ange coached.
There have been a couple of changes in individual players available but not in the overall quality of players.
Strength of opponent
The average FIFA ranking of teams Ange faced in his last 6 games was 77, in the 6 games since then it has been 52.
We know that FIFA rankings are BS. Syria against Ange were under-ranked because their “home” games were not in Syria. The gap in strength of opponent will reduce, then disappear as the sample size grows. Let’s see if After-Ange closes the gap on the table.
Ange was good but hurt the team by leaving
Ange Postecoglou is a divisive figure amongst Australian soccer fans. He is called everything from our greatest ever coach to a disaster for the national team. I think he was both.
Ange had a great record, he won us the Asian Cup! But he took a contract to coach the Socceroos until the end of the 2018 World Cup campaign. After qualifying the team he lacked the courage to see it through.
Sure there is a lot we don’t know, maybe the FFA were bad to work for, maybe the media were annoying. Geewiz, so everything was not perfect, have some fortitude and finish your job! It was obviously going to be difficult from the beginning. Do you think it was easy to coach Panama or England or Egypt to the World Cup? Ange was in a brilliant position, the position he chose!
The team should not have been left without a coach, and the Football Federation of Australia (FFA) should not have been put in the position of having to find a new coach, 6 months before the World Cup. Ange’s cowardly exit left us in the lurch and lead to the disastrous hiring decisions that followed.
Disastrous post-Ange coaching appointments
The Socceroos coaching appointments since Ange left have been terrible. In one case the FFA took the wrong approach and in the other case they appointed the wrong person.
Short term mercenary instead of long term leader
After Ange left the FFA should have found the right man for the job and hired him to lead us until the end of the 2022 World Cup campaign (5 years at the time). They should not have hired a short term mercenary just for the 2018 World Cup.
They got Bert Van Marwijk for 3 games; 2 losses and a draw. We had no direction or plan or identity. This was not BVM’s fault, he did his best in limiting circumstances. The Socceroos would be doing much better now if BVM was head coach on a 5 year contract.
Re-hire someone who failed last time
Re-appointing Graham Arnold was stupid, because he had already had the job and failed badly! The circumstances are almost identical to the last time around; he is taking over from a big name, short term, Dutch coach, right after the World Cup heading into the Asian cup.
His record last time was an abysmal 14 games for 5 wins 4 draws and 5 losses. That’s faltering because one of the “draws” was when we lost on penalties and were eliminated from a disastrous Asian Cup campaign. Remember he had one of best Socceroos squads ever, with players like like Aloisi, Bresciano, Cahill, Culina, Emerton, Kewell, Neil, Schwarzer and Veduka.
Unsurprisingly he is repeating his past performance. This is nothing against Arnie, he is a top bloke and a great servant of the game in Australia. This is entirely the FFAs fault for giving him a job he had already shown he is not up for.